Generic proceeding to consider the inflation factor to be used to set rates for electricity transmitters and electricity and natural gas distributors for the year 2022

EB-2021-0212

The Ontario Energy Board is commencing a hearing on its own motion to consider the inflation factor to be used to set rates for electricity transmitters and electricity and natural gas distributors for the year 2022.

The OEB is initiating this proceeding on its own motion to review the inflation factors that are to be used to set rates for the year 2022.

In November 2013, the OEB issued a Report of the Board on Rate Setting Parameters and Benchmarking under the Renewed Regulatory Framework for Ontario’s Electricity Distributors which established a framework for annual electricity distribution rate adjustments. The OEB has subsequently approved similar formulas for annual rate adjustments for electricity transmitters and natural gas distributors.

Under this framework the OEB established a formulaic approach to setting rates for years between major rate applications, whereby electricity transmitters and electricity and natural gas distributors (collectively, Utilities) have their rates adjusted annually using an OEB-approved formula that is tied to inflation (using several inflation indices published annually by Statistics Canada) and other factors intended to promote efficiency. The inflation rates and productivity factors in the OEB-approved formula are updated annually by the OEB based on macro-economic data.

The OEB’s preliminary calculations for 2022 rate adjustments suggest that the inflation indices typically used in the rate adjustment formulas may not be representative of the inflation that Utilities will experience in 2022.

Preliminary calculations using existing Statistics Canada data show the following estimated inflation factors for 2022 and the approved inflation factors used to adjust 2021 distribution and transmission rates. Actual distribution and transmission rate adjustments would also reflect adjustments for productivity and possibly other factors. A typical rate adjustment would have an offset of -0.3%, so that a 3.3% inflation factor would typically result in a 3.0% rate adjustment.

  Enbridge Electricity Transmission Electricity Distribution and EPCOR
2022 (estimate) 1.7% 2.5% 3.3%
2021 (approved) 2.0% 2.0% 2.2%

 

The 2022 inflation estimates are not expected to materially change when final calculations are made with updated Statistics Canada data in September 2021.

The OEB has been reviewing reasons for the changes in the inflation rates, and the differences in the inflation rates between the energy sectors of Enbridge, electricity transmitters, and electricity distributors and EPCOR. The non-labour index, the Implicit Price Index for National Gross Domestic Product, shows a 2020 over 2019 change of 1.7%.

By contrast, analysis shows that the labour inflation component of the inflation factor, Average Weekly Earnings (Ontario, all businesses), increased by about 7% from 2019 to 2020. According to Statistics Canada, the increases in Average Weekly Earnings and related statistics like Average Hourly Earnings, are largely affected by how COVID-19 lockdowns and other restrictions disproportionately affected, through removal from the active work force, lower wage-earning employees, relative to salaried employees, resulting in a higher average weekly earnings for the active workforce during the COVID-19 pandemic. This increase in the labour inflation component is a significant driver of the projected increases to the total inflation factors used to set rates for Utilities, while employees of Utilities are largely higher earning salaried workers in the labour force.

The OEB is considering three options:

  1. Continue to apply the existing methodology and formula (including the existing inflation indices) to the 2022 rate adjustments
  2. Extend the approved values for 2021 inflation rates for 2022 rate adjustments
  3. Update the 2022 inflation rates under the existing methodology using a suitable sub-index of Average Weekly Earnings or a related statistic, Average Hourly Earnings, that is more representative of labour inflation expected to be experienced by Utilities in 2022.

The OEB will also consider other options as presented, with supporting rationale, by parties.

This proceeding will focus solely on determining the values for 2022 inflation factors that would result in just and reasonable rates when used in rate adjustment applications for rates effective in 2022. It is not intended to be a review of the inflation factor methodology and formula, or the existing framework for setting rates through annual Price Cap IR, Revenue Cap IR or similar rate adjustment options made available by the OEB.

More information

Submit a letter of comment

You can submit a letter of comment that will be considered by the panel deciding the application. Unless the notice states otherwise, your letter of comment must be received by the OEB no later than 60 days after the publication or service date of the notice for the application. Your letter will be provided directly to the panel of Commissioners who will be deciding whether the application is approved. The panel will consider your comments in reaching their decision. The panel will only be able to consider comments which relate to issues which are within the authority of the OEB and relevant to the issues being considered by the panel.

More about commenting and privacy

More about commenting and privacy
All letters of comment sent to the OEB are placed on the public record. This means the letters can be seen at our offices and will be placed on our website. Before the letter of comment is placed on the public record, all personal (i.e. not business) contact information is removed, such as the individual's address, fax and phone numbers, and email address. The individual's name and the content of the letter will become part of the public record..

If you would like a response from the applicant, please send a copy of your letter directly to the applicant, including your contact information. The OEB removes your contact information from your letter for privacy reasons before it is posted to our website.Show less

This information will be visible on the OEB's public website.
Upload an attachment only if you need to submit additional information relating to your comment. Only PDF and Word files will be accepted.
Choose file
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Get updates about this application:

Or mail the below address with the reference number EB-2021-0212

Ontario Energy Board
P.O. Box 2319
2300 Yonge Street, 27th Floor
Toronto ON M4P 1E4
Attn: Registrar